CASE STUDY

The Verdict: A Perfect CX Hire for Pareto Legal

Pareto Legal came to us after struggling to find the right Client Experience Manager.

The challenge was finding someone with an unusual combination of legal marketing experience, performance marketing knowledge and strong client relationship skills.

Fortunately, we’d recruited for four almost identical roles for other US legal marketing agencies over the previous 18 months. We knew the market, had established relationships with relevant talent and, crucially, knew exactly what good looked like.

Client
Industry
Role
Client Experience Manager
01

The Client

Pareto Legal logo
Industry:

Pareto Legal is a US-based digital marketing agency specialising in helping law firms grow through SEO, paid media, lead generation and performance marketing.

Operating in a highly competitive market, the agency needs people who understand both digital marketing delivery and the commercial realities of managing law firm clients.

The Client Experience Manager would play an important role in maintaining those relationships, managing expectations and ensuring clients received the support needed to build lasting partnerships with the agency.

02

The Challenge

Pareto had struggled to find candidates who combined three distinct areas of expertise.

Performance marketing: A solid understanding of SEO, paid media and agency delivery.

Legal marketing: Experience working with law firms and understanding their expectations.

Client experience: The ability to manage relationships, build trust, handle expectations and drive retention.

They’d encountered candidates who were strong in one or two areas, but finding someone who brought all three together was proving difficult.

The challenge wasn’t simply finding an experienced client manager or a knowledgeable digital marketer. It was identifying someone who could understand the work, understand the client and bring both together effectively.

03

How We Got to Work

After a detailed briefing with Bo and the team, we knew precisely what Pareto needed.

We’d recruited for four almost identical positions across other US legal marketing agencies over the previous 18 months, giving us a clear understanding of the talent pool, the backgrounds to target and the candidates most likely to succeed.

But perhaps more importantly, we knew what good looked like.

Having recruited for this particular type of role repeatedly, we understood how to distinguish between someone with relevant experience on paper and someone who could genuinely manage demanding legal clients, understand performance marketing delivery and build lasting relationships.

We knew what to probe for, which questions to ask and how to qualify candidates properly before introducing them.

That combination of market knowledge, established relationships and specialist recruitment experience allowed us to move quickly without compromising on quality.

04

The Result

Bianca Gonzales was selected as Pareto Legal’s new Client Experience Manager.

We presented seven candidates, with two progressing to the final stage. Both were strong contenders, but Bianca’s combination of legal marketing, performance marketing and client experience made her the standout choice.

From the initial briefing to securing Bianca, the entire process took just two weeks.

A role Pareto had struggled to fill was successfully closed with someone who brought together all three areas of expertise they needed.

For us, this demonstrated the value of genuine specialisation. Knowing where to find candidates matters, but knowing what good looks like when you find them is what makes the difference.

Seven candidates presented. Two finalists. One successful hire. Two weeks from brief to hire.

0
candidates presented
0
finalists
0
successful hire
05

Facing a similar hiring challenge?

We specialise in recruitment across SEO & AEO, Paid Media, Digital PR, Growth Marketing, eCommerce and SaaS Marketing.

SUCCESS STORIES

Results That Speak For Themselves

A selection of successful hires and long-term partnerships across the digital marketing industry.

Explore Anonymised Profiles of the Top Talent in Our Network

These talented individuals are looking for their next opportunity. If any profiles pique your interest, let us know!